Dustin Hoffman

Ben Floss

Susan Sarandon

Jojo Floss

Jake Gyllenhaal

Joe Nast

Alexia Landeau

Cheryl

Ellen Pompeo

Bertie Knox

Richard Messing

Rabbi

Lev Friedman

Cantor

Bob Clendenin

Server #1

Jim Fyfe

Server #2

Mary Ellen Trainor

Mrs. Meyerson

Richard Fancy

Mr. Meyerson

Marcia Mitzman Gaven

Fashion Plate

Holly Hunter

Mona Camp

Gordon Clapp

Tanner

Dabney Coleman

Mike Mulcahey

Colombe Jacobsen-Derstine

Patty

Allan Corduner

Stan Michaels

Careena Melia

Diana Floss

Gary Hetzler

Speedwalker

Mary Catherine Garrison

Caroline

Audrey Marie Anderson

Audrey Anders

Virginia Newcomb

Cheryl's Friend #2

Elizabeth Janas

Cheryl's Friend #3

Dee Nelson

Waitress

McNally Sagal

Mrs. Tippet

Roxanne Hart

June Mulcahey

Lisa Anne Hillman

Jillian Mulcahey

Rachel Singer

Rhonda Ketch

Alexandra Hoffman

Diner Granddaughter

Richard T. Jones

Ty

Lenny Clarke

Gordy

Robert Wahlberg

Pinky

Tom Carey

Baxter

Phil Reeves

Mr. Don Tippet

John Balma

Walter Ketch

Tom Dahlgren

Judge

Mark Lotito

Diner Manager

Caitlin McKenna

Bar Voice (voice)

Jessica Gee-George

Bar Voice (voice)

Paul Pape

Bar Voice (voice)

Jillian Armenante

Caterer (uncredited)

David Wheeler

Diner Grandfather