Jennifer Aniston

Nina Borowski

Paul Rudd

George Hanson

Alan Alda

Sidney Miller

Nigel Hawthorne

Rodney Fraser

John Pankow

Vince McBride

Tim Daly

Robert Joley

Allison Janney

Constance Miller

Steve Zahn

Frank Hanson

Amo Gulinello

Paul James

Bruce Altman

Dr. Goldstein

Kevin Carroll

Louis Crowley

Lauren Pratt

Sally Miller

Kali Rocha

Melissa Marx

Lena Cardwell

Girl at Community Center

Natalie B. Kikkenborg

Girl at Community Center

Hayden Panettiere

Mermaid

Lauren Chen

Violin Player

Liam Aiken

Nathan

Janet Zarish

Dinner Guest

Ellen Tobie

Dinner Guest

Virl Andrick

Dinner Guest

Robert C. Lee

Dinner Guest

Bradley White

Stephen Saint

Marilyn Dobrin

Mrs. Sarni

Midori Nakamura

Nina's Colleague

Joan Copeland

Madame Reynolds

Kate Jennings Grant

Kennedy

Salem Ludwig

Mr. Shapiro

Antonia Rey

Mrs. Ochoa

Danny Darrow

Nina's Dance Partner

Sean Rademaker

School Child

Heather Thompson

School Child

Mary McIlvaine

Nurse

Lisa-Erin Allen

Nurse

Samia Shoaib

Suni

Doug Wert

Father

Shawn Phelan

Son

Edward James Hyland

Doctor

Gabriel Macht

Steve Casillo

John Roland

TV Anchor

Rosanna Scotto

TV Anchor

Miguel Maldonado

Colin Powell

Peter Maloney

Desk Clerk

Bette Henritze

Mrs. Skinner

Iraida Polanco

Carmelita

Sarah Knowlton

Caroline Colucci

Steven Ochoa

Waiter

Kia Goodwin

Juliet

Daniel Cosgrove

Trotter Bull

Damian Young

Romeo & Juliet Director

Rebecca Eichenberger

Wedding Guest

Jane Bodle

Wedding Guest

Audra McDonald

Wedding Singer

Fanni Green

Nurse

Sarah Hyland

Molly

Paz de la Huerta

13-Year-Old Sally

Jeffrey M. Marchetti

Parent

Susan Bradford

Parent

Ava Lee Scott

Woman in Central Park (uncredited)