Danny DeVito

Buddy Hall

Matthew Broderick

Steve Finch

Kristin Davis

Kelly Finch

Kristin Chenoweth

Tia Hall

Alia Shawkat

Madison Finch

Fred Armisen

Gustave

Jorge Garcia

Wallace

Dylan Blue

Carter Finch

Kelly Aldridge

Ashley Hall

Sabrina Aldridge

Emily Hall

Sean O'Bryan

Mayor Young

Gillian Vigman

Gerta

Ryan Devlin

Bob Murray

SuChin Pak

Self

Jackie Burroughs

Mrs. Ryor

Garry Chalk

Sheriff Dave

Nicola Peltz

Mackenzie

Zak Santiago

Fireworks Guy

David James Lewis

Ted

Daniel Bacon

Ed

Ken Kramer

Mr. Murray

Jill Morrison

Gail

Alf Humphreys

Hardware Store Employee

Brenda Crichlow

News Reporter #1

Jill Krop

Reporter #2

Agam Darshi

News Producer

David Stuart

Oblivious Dad

Quinn Lord

Santa Kid

Nathaniel DeVeaux

Main Street Passerby #1

Fulvio Cecere

Town Passerby

Eliza Norbury

Mary in the Manger

Randi Lynne

Caroler #1

Dan Joffre

Caroler #2

Aurora Faulkner-Killam

Caroler

Melissa Howell

Caroler

Lori Johnson

Caroler

David Shaw

Caroler

Myles Wolfe

Caroler

Ty Olsson

Trucker

Stephen Holmes

UPS Guy

Andrew Hedge

City Employee

Cory Monteith

Madison's Date

Cassidy Bot-Devire

Little Girl (uncredited)

Aaron Craven

Businessman Dad (uncredited)

Blair Gorrell

Carnival Fan (uncredited)

Rachel Lana Li

Spectator (uncredited)

Lochlyn Munro

Ted (uncredited)

Kal Penn

Amit Sayid (uncredited)

Caroline Redekopp

Mackenzie's Mother (uncredited)

Arden Rhine

Woman (uncredited)

Calum Worthy

Boy On a Bike (uncredited)