Lauren Holly

Claudia

Edward Burns

Charlie

Jon Bon Jovi

Michael

Blythe Danner

Claudia's Mom

Connie Britton

Kelly

Ellen McElduff

Waitress

Jennifer Esposito

Teresa

Kathleen Doyle

Mrs. Ryan

Nick Sandow

Goldie

Welker White

Missy

Kevin Heffernan

Guy in Diner #1

Mark Schulte

Guy in Diner #2

Kaili Vernoff

Alice

John Ventimiglia

Tony the Pizza Guy

Leah Gray

Girl in Bar #1

Marcia DeBonis

Girl in Bar #2

Shari Albert

Girl in Bar #3

Susan May Pratt

Annie

Stuart Rudin

The Foot

Matty Delia

Bugsy

Margaret O'Neill

Maggie

Chris McGovern

Sully

Colleen McQuade

Kelly

John Moss

Marty

Imelda O'Reilly

Girl at Bar

Brian Donahue

Bouncer (uncredited)

Capucine Lyons

Girl at Bar (uncredited)

Tim Maloney

Guy in Bar (uncredited)