Leighton Meester

Nina Ostroff

Hugh Laurie

David Walling

Alia Shawkat

Vanessa Walling

Allison Janney

Carol Ostroff

Catherine Keener

Paige Walling

Adam Brody

Toby Walling

Oliver Platt

Terry Ostroff

Ian Helfer

Christmas Caroler

Marceline Hugot

Christmas Caroler

Curtis McClarin

Christmas Caroler

Jay Reiss

Christmas Caroler

Sarah Saltzberg

Christmas Caroler

Aya Cash

Maya

Sam Rosen

Ethan

Hoon Lee

Henry

Heidi Kristoffer

Meredith Lovett

Arthur Anderson

Innkeeper

Damian Young

Gideon Allen

Betsy Aidem

Anne Allen

Paul Fears

Ultimate Frisbee Player

Tim Guinee

Roger

Mando Alvarado

Chef

John Dossett

Shelly

John Srednicki

Waiter

Jeffrey Mowery

Gambler (uncredited)