Joshua M. Lester

The Pie Guy

Skye LaFontaine

Sophia

Greg Hirshland

Garret

Sam Anker

Tommy

Amanda Westlake

Jackie Collins

Colette Freedman

The Therapist

Charlie R. Parker

Kim

Julia Fae

Baylee

Keegan Ferguson

Supervisor

Ed Regine

Dad

Varda Appleton

Mom

Shikira Saul

Ex-Girlfriend

Neil Lars

Nolan

Deidre Lee

Goth Girl

Amanda Rivers

July

Dante Bisson

Barry (TV Show)

Louie Caceres

Pie Bartender

August Edwards

Ryan

Jorge Espinoza

Leonard (TV Show)

Laurie Gray

Pie Bar Owner

Carolina Montenegro

Emily

Arielle Raycene

The Blonde

Thomas Sapin

Half Naked Guy

Logan Solberg

Bartender

Eddie Streeter

Brooklyn Pizza Worker

Elle Sunkara

Dr. Stephenson

Colleen Tholen

Co-Worker

Kaleb Tholen

Co-Worker

Ndi Wilson

Middle Bar Date