Brooke Bradshaw

Veronica (New Years)

Wesley Alley

Uncle Bob (Christmas)

Whitney Alley

Party Guest (Christmas)

Michael Antosy

Eran Lawrence (Easter)

Amy Baklini

Doctor's Voicemail (voice)

Ronan Barbour

Doyle (St. Patrick's Day)

Adam Beigel

Kris Anderson (Christmas)

Michelle Bernard

Judy (Chanukah)

Darren Lynn Bousman

Orignial Killer Santa (Christmas)

Alexandra Boylan

Josi (Thanksgiving)

Arielle Brachfeld

Girl in Woods (Halloween)

Hannah Carleton

Home Buyer (Halloween)

Brian C. Chenworth

New Killer Santa Clause (Christmas)

Micah Cohen

Party Goer (New Years)

Brandon Conner

Jeffery (Halloween)

Ivet Corvea

Gloria (4th of July)

Francis Cronin

Sheamus G (St. Patrick's Day)

Taylor Cross

Dan (New Years)

Lenora Elisabeth

Ciara (St. Patrick's Day)

Michael J. Epstein

Mr. Keane (St. Patrick's Day)

Bradley Fowler

Party Guest (Christmas)

Charlie Frohne

Radio News Reporter (Easter) (voice)

John K.D. Graham

Monster (Thanksgiving)

Josh Hammond

Jesse (4th of July)

Alethea Hnatko-Cho

Clara (St. Patrick's Day)

Christopher M. Jimenez

Party Guest (Christmas)

Breeanna Judy

Party Guest (Christmas)

Darius Karsas

Father Time (New Years)

Neil King

Party Guest (Christmas)

Erica Lamkin

Laura (Labor Day)

Matt Larson

Allen (New Years)

Lisa Mason Lee

Diane (New Years)

Bobbi Sue Luther

Party Guest (Christmas)

Rene Michelle Aranda

Party Goer (New Years)

Micah Cohler

Party Guest (New Years / Father Time)

Raiven Lynn

Shawna (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Andrew Maiorano

Raven Entity (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)

Hercules Magnus

Hercules (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)

Amanda Markowitz

Tara / Party Game Player 2 (New Years / Father Time)

Kevin Marron

Mr. G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Victoria Matlock

Jessica / Party Game Player 1 (New Years / Father Time)

Marty McFly

Marty (Easter / Forty Winks)

Brian McGrath

Strange Walker (Easter / Forty Winks)

Matt McWilliams

Home Buyer (Halloween / Candy)

Nell Nakkan

Mrs. Keane (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Maitlyn Pezzo

Holly (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Jodie Panek

Mom (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)

Demetrius Phillips

Kevin (4th of July / 4th of July)

Nicolas Quijano

Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Rachel Rath

Mrs. G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Patrick Joseph Rieger

Mike (Halloween / Candy)

Benton Robertson

Patrick G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)

Charlotte Rothwell

TV News Reporter (Easter / Forty Winks) (voice)

Angelica Salek

Beth Anderson (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Brian Sapir

Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Curtis Schultz

Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Daniel Schweiger

Soloman (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)

Steven Shea

Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Bright)

Catherine Siggins

Aunty Lorna McGlory (St. Patrick's / Becoming Patrick)

Dan Snowden

Real Estate Man (Halloween / Candy)

Jessica Sonneborn

Jane / Betty (4th of July / 4th of July, Labor Day / Labor Day)

Michael Varrati

Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Jennifer Vincent

Crystal (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)

Jeff Wiesen

Cop / James (4th of July / 4th of July, Labor Day / Labor Day)

Wes Sneeringer

911 Operator (uncredited)

Khaled Zakher

Store Clerk (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)

Lauren Chavez-Myers

Lilith Hicks (Easter)

DaNae Martinez

Charlotte Anderson (Christmas / Merry and Fright)