Mary Martin

Peter Pan

Cyril Ritchard

Mr. Darling / Captain Hook

Kathleen Nolan

Wendy / Jane

Margalo Gillmore

Mrs. Darling

Sondra Lee

Tiger Lily

Heller Halliday

Liza

Joe E. Marks

Smee

Norman Shelly

Nana / Crocodile

Michael Allen

John

Tom Halloran

Michael

David Bean

Slightly

Stanley Stenner

Curly

Alan Sutherland

First Twin

Harold Daye

Second Twin

Ian Tucker

Tootles

Paris Theodore

Nibs

Richard Wyatt

Lion

Joan Tewkesbury

Ostrich

Peggy Maurer

Wendy Grown-Up

Robert Vanselow

Starkey

Richard Winter

Cecco

Frank Lindsay

Noodler

Carl Erbele

Kangaroo

Patricia Wheel

Narrator