Elijah Wood

Bill Hagmaier

Luke Kirby

Ted Bundy

Aleksa Palladino

Carolyn Lieberman

Robert Patrick

Roger Depue

W. Earl Brown

Warden Wilkenson

Gilbert Owuor

Assistant Warden Paul Decker

Christian Clemenson

Doctor James Dobson

Hugo Armstrong

Colorado Investigator

Nican Robinson

Utah Investigator

Will Harris

Oregon Investigator

Emily Berry

Idaho Investigator

Steven Pritchard

Agent Montgomery

Jarrett Sleeper

Assistant Warden McNeal

Doug Cox

Minister Lawrence

Tom Virtue

Agent Strauss

John Wilcox

Agent Meyers

Austin Uku

Agent Douglas

Mac Brandt

Guard Paluger

Mona Lee Wylde

Psychiatrist

Jessica Lynn Skinner

Woman in Car

Kate Adams

Woman on Street

David Salsa

Guard Flank

Richard Blackmon

Guard Simone

Allison Baver

Masha Tanner (uncredited)

Rachel Mysior

Victim (uncredited)