Diane Foster

Audrey

David Backus

The Orphan Killer

Matt Farnsworth

Mike

James McCaffrey

Detective Jones

John Savage

Detective Walker

Karen Young

Sister Mary

Charlotte Maier

Sister Constance

Spencer List

Young Marcus

Dana DeVestern

Young Audrey

Edward Winrow

Father Chuck

Devin Foster

Skateboarder

Ramon Villa

Sanchez the Janitor

Seif El Bawdrey

Vinny the Janitor

Olivia Rosendahl

Jump Rope Orphan

Samantha Matarante

Urban Ledgend Teen #1

April Hautea

Urban Ledgend Teen #2

Ivan Martin

Math Teacher

Margot White

Jenny Miller

Mike Doyle

Dad Miller

Golden Farnsworth

Boy Marcus

Ivy Farnsworth

Baby Audrey

Hector Lincoln

Intruder - Murderer

Allison Salvetti

Screaming Orphan

Walter Masterson

Marcus Miller

Ezra Knight

Simon - Orderly

Jon David Casey

Jerry - Orderly

Matthew Arkin

Bob - Orderly

Linda Bothwell-Murphy

Naughty Nun

Lesline Lewis

Jamaican Nun

Celina Vignaud

Orphan Kid

Michaela M. Hill

Orphan Kid

Ian Colletti

Orphan Kid Playing Basketball

Lucian Maisel

Orphan Kid Playing Basketball

Richard Charles Stevens

Robert

Kenya Brome

Reporter (uncredited)

Federico Castelluccio

Dr. Morris (uncredited)

Brian Delate

John (uncredited)

Maria Diaz

Nun (uncredited)

Michael Ray Escamilla

Hector (uncredited)

Matthew Gooley

Orderly (uncredited)

Carrie Needham

Mike's Mother (uncredited)

Drew Needham

Policeman (uncredited)

Karen Olivo

Angie (uncredited)

Josh Pesin

Policeman (uncredited)

Jeff Velez

News Photographer (uncredited)

William Wayne

Marcus' Orderly (uncredited)