Martin Landau

Robert

Ellen Burstyn

Mary

Adam Scott

Mike

Elizabeth Banks

Alex

Har Mar Superstar

Peter (as Sean Tillmann)

Kali Cook

Cute Girl

Chris Wiig

Co-Worker #1 (as Christopher Why)

M. Michele Phillips

Co-Worker #2

Tina Dixon

Post Woman (as Christine Dixon)

Mary Husar

Co-Worker #3

Scott Beehner

Co-Worker #4

Todd Fink

Fancy Waiter

Ross Brockley

Grumpy Carriage Driver

Alex Curbeam

Damien Montgonmery

Michael Leach Jr.

Sled Kid #2

Nick Hernandez

Sled Kid #3

Leo Fitzpatrick

Pharmacist

Judith Kathryn Hart

Jacky

Jules Blight

Lisa

Mark Booker

Harold

Mark Kresl

Rufus

Zoey Newman

Michelle

James Devney

Buck

Melissa Jarecke

Party Woman

Sean O'Connell

Young Mike

Randi-Shane Knox

Young Alex