Carl Crew

Jeffrey Dahmer

Christopher 'CJ' Smith

Young Jeffrey Dahmer

Donna Stewart Bowen

Mother

Jeanne Bascom

Grandmother

Cassidy Phillips

Steven

G-Jo Reed

Steve

Rowdy Jackson

Richard

Andrew Christian English

Anthony

Don Jose Christian

Anthony

Douglas Moore

Raymond

Lando St. Clair

Edward

Dominic Anthony

Ernest / Matt

John Anthony Williams

David

Peter Napoles

Konerak

Aaron Braxton

Tracy

Alex Scott

Ronald

Keith Gearhart

James

Cornelius Williams

Bobby

Rhonno Ket

Sounthome

Melanite Haymon

Sandra

Michelle Silveira

Glenda

Christian Voss

Bar Pick-Up

Jordan Cox

Baby

Jill Cox

Lady with Baby

Laura Tesone

Lady in Car

Rick Bower

Clergyman

Marklen Kennedy

Composite Victim

Lance Mitchell

Prostitute / Victim

Lisa Marks

Probation Officer

Deane Nelson

Police Officer

Lana Lloyd

Police Officer

Jason Hurst

Police Officer

Jeff Theis

Police Officer

Mario Capra

Police Officer

Marz Jagger

Police Officer

Michael Millazo

Police Officer

Suzie Campbell

Police Officer

Vonda Shrader

Police Officer

Todd Fournier

Policeman #1

Brian Murphy

Policeman #2

Kent Moyer

Policeman #3

Lendy Jones

Policeman #4

Walter McBride

Policeman #5

Enrique Gavilanes

Policeman #6

L.P. Brown III

Policeman #7

Bredy Gamble

Policeman #8

Deborah Kellar

Neighbor #1

Hilda Boulware

Neighbor #2

David Angelis

Bartender #1

Kimberly Krank

Bartender #2

Chuck Record

Bartender #3

John Collins

Jeffrey's Dad (voice)

Sherman Sherman

Victim's Mom (voice)

Josephine O'Keefe

Lady Bartender (voice)