Quinn Shephard

Abigail

Nadia Alexander

Melissa

Trieste Kelly Dunn

Jennifer

Marcia DeBonis

Ms. Cohen

Tessa Albertson

Ellie

Sarah Mezzanotte

Sophie

Owen Campbell

TJ

Luke Slattery

Eric

Tate Donovan

Robert

Chris Messina

Jeremy Woods

Elizabeth Howell

Abigail's Mother

Carlyle Owens

Abigail's Father

Geneva Carr

Mrs. Howell

Whitney Harris

Melissa's mother (voice)

Lily Houghton

Lily / Drama Student

Phelan Tupik

Phelan / Drama Student

Michael Jefferson

Hallway Teacher

Larry Mitchell

Officer Dolan

Julie Dwoskin

Drama Student

Sherilyn James

Drama Student

Jack Labbe

Drama Student

Ashley La Selva

Drama Student

Michelle Martinez

Drama Student