Jesse Metcalfe

Tom Endler

Robin Givens

Principal Kinney

Melissa Joan Hart

Grace Wesley

Brad Heller

School Attorney

Ernie Hudson

Judge Stennis

Hayley Orrantia

Brooke Thawley

Pat Boone

Walter Wesley

Paul Kwo

Martin Yip

Trisha LaFache

Amy Ryan

Jon Lindstrom

Superintendent Jim Powell

Maria Canals-Barrera

Catherine Thawley

Benjamin Ochieng

Reverend Jude

Sadie Robertson

Marlene

Fred Thompson

Senior Pastor

David A.R. White

Pastor Dave Hill

Ray Wise

Peter Kane

Tommy Blaze

Waiter

Rice Broocks

Rice Broocks

Mallory Hardin Brooks

Susan Stone

Natalie Canerday

Mrs. Rizzo

Ron Clemens

Rev. Dave Double

Verda Davenport

First Teacher

Abigail Duhon

Jessica

Taylor Eaves

Goth Girl

Kayla Esmond

Crazy Cat Lady

Mary Faulkner

Frazzled Teacher

Jenn Gotzon Chandler

Fashionista

Gary Habermas

Gary Habermas

Lauren Harper

Sunny Barista

Candyce Hinkle

Salvation Army Lady

Mike Huckabee

Mike Huckabee

Andres Hudson

Bailiff

Mark Whitman Johnson

County Clerk

Corey Koteras

Slacker Kid

Mario Luna

Prospective Juror

Travis McCoy

Male Journalist

Eamonn McCrystal

Simon Boyle

Gary Newton

Paramedic

Vivian Norman

Norma

Chanley Painter

V.P. of Teachers Union

Taylor Quick

Teenage Girl

Paige Martin Reynolds

Pharmacist

Kimberly Scott

Female Juror

Gianna Simone

Elizabeth Healy

John Stiritz

Older Man

Lee Strobel

Lee Strobel

Ryk St. Vincent

Jury Forman

J. Warner Wallace

Jim Warner Wallace

Jesse Wang

Martin's Father

Michael Tait

The Newsboys

Duncan Phillips

The Newsboys

Jeff Frankenstein

The Newsboys

Jody Davis

The Newsboys

Cara Alvey

Concert Patron (uncredited)

Danny Campbell

Jury Extra (uncredited)

Gregory Chisley

Courtroom observer (uncredited)

Brock Clyburn

Medical Staff (uncredited)

Ann Cogswell

Food Truck Patron (uncredited)

Margaret Cogswell

Gallery Observer (uncredited)

Greg Fallon

Lawyer (uncredited)

Kenneth Gaddie

Protestor (uncredited)

Latiera Golliday

Waitress (uncredited)

Lauren Hall

Extra (uncredited)

Mary Handiboe

Courtroom Observer (uncredited)

Bryan Harp

Paramedic (uncredited)

Spencer Kane Hess

Student (trouble maker) (uncredited)

Brent Holt

Protester Shaking Jesse Metcalfe Hand (uncredited)

Misty Jezierski

Supporter (uncredited)

D. Matt Jordan

Juror #6 (uncredited)

Chuck King

Background (uncredited)

James Mainard O'Connell

Timid Pastor (uncredited)

Star McCann

Courtroom Observer / Protester (uncredited)

Angela Sherrill Merriott

Courtroom Observer (uncredited)

Alanna Hamill Newton

Juror (uncredited)

Carmen Patterson

Courtroom Gallery / Protestor (uncredited)

Arnold John Popa III

Courtroom Observer / Reporter (uncredited)

Nicole A. Randall

Concert patron (uncredited)

Nokona Redus

Classmate (uncredited)

Ashley Richardson

Extra (uncredited)

Taylor Robirts

Protester (uncredited)

Samantha M Shaw

Protester (uncredited)

Isaac Slatton

Protester (uncredited)

Shawn C Smith

Concert Attendee (uncredited)

Kristina Strava

Concert Patron (uncredited)

Cameron Taylor

Lawyer Assistant (uncredited)

Stacey McBryde Valley

Extra (uncredited)

Mindy Van Kuren

Reporter (uncredited)

Terri Whitehurst

Concert Patron (uncredited)

Don E. Willis

Extra (uncredited)

Carey Scott

Richard Thawley