Seth Peterson

Robbie Levinson

Bruce Davison

Pastor Boyd

Chad Donella

Chris Boyd

Cindy Pickett

Barbara McCoy

Brian J. Smith

Trey McCoy

Susan Blakely

Martha Boyd

Lin Shaye

Kathleen Slansky

Farah White

Det. Elizabeth Fisher

Giancarlo Esposito

Detective Esposito

Sean Hennigan

Jim McCoy

Brandy Little

Stella

Ben Bathman

Connor Davis

Luke King

Alton Kachim

Earl Browning III

Detective Loy

Scarlett McAlister

Doctor Kucera

Connor Gewin

4-year-old Trey

Tyler Farris

10-year-old Trey

Trevor Sterling Stovall

Fisher's Son

Jason Hair-Wynn

Boy in Jail (uncredited)

Preston Strother

Boy in Church (uncredited)

Tyler Strother

Boy in Church (uncredited)

Cyrus Thompson

Boy in the Park (uncredited)

Tom Marcantel

Father Tim

Hana Kapp

Salesperson

Cas Dodgen

Policeman

Brock Cravy

Young Man

Kellie Rasberry

Carla, Robbie's Coworker

Dee Hennigan

Daycare Teacher

Keni LaTronico

Robbie's Mother (as Keni la Troncio)

Vernon Reeves

Seth's Father

Juan Gonzalez

Private Investigator

Heidie

Phoebe

Libby Villari

Shirley

Delia Rose

Church Member (as Delia Johnson)

Jenn Wright

Church Officer #1

Joe L. Blevins

Deacon (uncredited)

Nathan Childs

Police Officer (uncredited)

Phil Harrington

Doctor on Ward (uncredited)

Aaron Holt

CSI Agent (uncredited)

Christopher Holt

Sunday School Boy (uncredited)

Jennifer Holt

Child on Playground (uncredited)

Kevin Holt

Day Care Boy (uncredited)

Nicole Holt

Detective / Funeral Guest (uncredited)

Phillip Lanier

Choir Singer (uncredited)

Tiffany McManus

Sunday School Kid (uncredited)

Jimmy Paleschic

Crime Scene Investigator (uncredited)

Sloane Schoeneberg

Church Member (uncredited)

Summer Selby

Precinct Worker (uncredited)