Paul McCloskey

Wayne Montgomery

Barbara Lessin

Andrea Montgomery

Brinke Stevens

Julie

Bruce DeSantis

Todd Montgomery

Emily Spiegel

Monica Montgomery

Michael J. Panichelli Jr.

Detective John Haynes

Jeff Watson

Joe Mitchell

Tanisha Dungee

Teresa Mitchell

Benjamin P. Ablao Jr.

Detective Chris Dolendo

Joey Garrison

Jared

Stacey Lowery

Olivia Hutton

Dave Wascavage

Richard Kemmerling

Melissa Torrence

Karen Wilson

Beth Sikma

Kim

Erick Kniesler

Jonathan

Bill Jackson

Matt

Niki Kehagias

Marcia

Shree Holman

Diana

Kate Holloway

Holly

Jay Cusack

Jeffrey

Yolanda Irizarry

Juanita

Debra Lee Wylie

Victim

Fran Slaczka

Women's Retreat Victim #1

Sue Morrow

Women's Retreat Victim #2

Karen Kennedy

Women's Retreat Victim #3

Mary Brown

Women's Retreat Victim #4

Steve Brown

Pastor Vernon Cole (deleted scenes)

Denise Smiley

Carolyn Jackson (deleted scenes)

John Larsen

Ron Hayford (deleted scenes)

Chris Keller

Amy (deleted scenes)

Meredith Fagioli

Juanita (voice) (deleted scenes)

Anthony Spadaccini

Derek Wilson (deleted scenes)

Mario DeSantis

Mike Montgomery (deleted scenes)

Keith Pyle

Doug Montgomery (deleted scenes)

James J. Ward

Scott Ratliff (deleted scenes)