William McNamara

Matthew Anderson

Elisabeth Shue

Natalie

Dylan Walsh

Michael Anderson

Peewee Love

T.J.

Steve Zurk

Father Anderson

Ilse Earl

Mrs. Piccalo

Ara Madzounian

Jesus

Tony Fabozzi

Ford

Brett Murray

Young Matthew

Justin Taylor

Young Michael

Jonathan Groves

Leonard

Sandra Thigpen

Gina

Glen Trotiner

Dwight

Jennifer Thompson

Crystal

Jessica Elizabeth Forres

Nadine

Estella McNair

Sara

Edgar Allan Poe IV

Cabbie

Fred Buch

Uncle Leland

Eleanor Garth

Aunt Bitsy

Paul Sylvan

Cop at Pool

Parris Buckner

Cop at Pool

Leslie Erganian

Mother

Jody Wilson

Deputy Sheriff

Alex Dominguez

Clerk (Uncredited)

Bently Tittle

Guy in the Lineup (Uncredited)

Julian Valdes

Taxi Driver (Uncredited)