Mackenzie Rosman

Ava

Shawn C. Phillips

Mick

Richard Moll

Finch

Jayme Bohn

Alisyn

Eliot Brasseaux

Nerd

Amy Brassette

Vicky Brubaker

Sloane Coe

Cicely

Robert Aberdeen

Museum Curator

Chelsea Bruland

Car Wash Girl

Kim Collins

Brubaker

Dave Davis

Blaise

Brooke Hurring

Taylor

Lucky Johnson

Mayor Stahl

Ben Lemoine

Reporter

Angela Meredith Furst

Co-Ed

Jaren Mitchell

Cameron

Thomas Francis Murphy

Sheriff Martin

Liann Pattison

Taylor's Mom

Han Soto

Ernest

Michelle DeVito

Concerned Citizen

Ronnie Hooks

Arlene (Sheriff's Dispatcher)

Rhonda Laizer

Mayor's Wife

Tim Taylor

Deputy Hendricks