Kevin Costner

Self - Host

Gia Rose Patel

Mary

Ethan Thorne

Joseph

Corinne Furman

Rachel Young

Paulina Gálvez

Raya

Mohamed Zouaoui

Joachim

Chaouqi Abdellatif

Asher

Anthony Barclay

King Herod

Kods Joundoul

Anne

Sinan Sicimoğlu

Panthera

Saif Al-Warith

Angel Gabriel

Corinne Furman

Cousin Rachel

Marco Lo Chiatto

Heralder Angel

Ibrahim Elouahabi

Young Shepherd Obed

Faycal Zaglet

Shepherd Abel

Madi Grace Cunningham

Queen Mariamne

Meher Baluch

Salome

Ché Grant

Antipater

Zina Badran

Rachel (David's Mother)

Robert Goodman

Simeon

Mansour Badri

Magi Melchior

Hamid Boutbaldine

Magi Gaspar

Mohamed Bamoula

Magi Balthazar

Joudia Ait Chatton

Newborn Jesus

Soulaimane El Tahiry

Newborn Jesus

Qusay El Bouhali

Young Jesus

Alex Vasu Rajan-Iyer

Judas of Gamala

Mikey Bharj

Moshe

Abdesselam Bouhasni

Magi Translator

Batoul Marie Prenant

Old Mary(as Marie-Prenant Batoul)

Alejandro Barrios

Legionnaire

Francis Chan

Self - Interviewee

Lynn H. Cohick

Self - Interviewee

Teo Hayashi

Self - Interviewee

Jodi Magness

Self - Interviewee

Vishal Mangalwadi

Self - Interviewee

Hassan Nogot

Traveler Caleb

Ilham Oujri

Destroyed Village Survivor

Sean Raftis

Self - Interviewee

Imrane Ahabchane

Young Traveler Daniel(uncredited)

Taha Mesbah

Rebel Scout(uncredited)

Stefano Venturi

Elderly Priest(uncredited)

Alin Wishka

Heli (Josephs Father)(uncredited)