Mary Stuart Masterson

Jenny Hill

Hart Bochner

Miller Brown

Stephen Blake

James Miller

Fionnula Flanagan

Mrs. Hill

Cec Verrell

Sally

Daphne Zuniga

Young Mrs. Miller

Melissa Moore

Miss Saunders

Reed Hollister

Townsperson

Barbara Dow

Mrs. Hill's Friend

Alix Koromzay

Saloon Girl

Colin Firth

Barber (uncredited)

Eleanor Baggett

Older Mrs. Miller

Pat Atkins

Mrs. Russell

Shea Dejon

Young Miller

Morgan Stuart

Young Jenny

Ryan Slater

Young James

Jonathan Tripp

Opera Singer

Janet Momjian

Opera Singer

Raymond De Felitta

Piano Player

Jackie Stansbury

Saloon Girl

Kathy Messick

Saloon Girl

Stephen Cole

Priest

Tom Mustin

Town Mayor

Travis Jordan Marsh

Baby James Miller

Cameron Frankley

Card Cheat

Hank Stone

Card Cheat

Bob Shurtleff

Card Cheat

Lori Ashton

Saloon Dancer

Michael Sladek

Laborer

Michael Latshaw

Townsperson

Heidi Amurri

Townsperson (as Heidi Lund)

Richard Barlow

Townsperson

Janice Dejon

Townsperson

Sharon Chatten

Townsperson