Sydney Sweeney

Millie Calloway

Amanda Seyfried

Nina Winchester

Brandon Sklenar

Andrew Winchester

Michele Morrone

Enzo

Indiana Elle

Cece Winchester

Sarah Cooper

Pam

Elizabeth Perkins

Mrs. Winchester

Ellen Tamaki

Patrice

Megan Ferguson

Jilliane

Amanda Joy Erickson

Suzanne

Alaina Surgener

Amanda

Peter Colandro

Cashier

Alexandra Seal

Officer Jessica Connors

Lamar Baucom-Slaughter

Officer Stanley

Don DiPetta

Officer Jenkins

Kathy Costa McKeown

Ballet Instructor

Cailen Fu

Hotel Desk Clerk

Brian D. Cohen

Detective Smythe

Arabella Olivia Clark

Young Nina (8yrs)

Ken Barnett

Professor

Matt Walton

Lynch

Maury Ginsberg

Therapist

Piper Rae Patterson

Pretty Nurse

Sophia Bunnell

Kelsey

Jeffrey Bean

Andrew's Reverend

Ellen Adair

Lisa

Jen Egan

Prison Guard

Bryce Biederman

College Boy (uncredited)