Samuel Dunning

Tim Travers

Felicia Day

Delilah

Joel McHale

James Bunratty

Danny Trejo

Royce

Keith David

The Simulator

Alex Terzieff

Goon Squad, The Gunner

Tony Doupe

Perpetual Bar Patron

Stimson Snead

Helter

David Babbitt

Delivery Guy / Tim Travers lookalike

Nicole Murray

Bartender

Jeff Hilliard

Goon Squad, Gun man

Jhon Goodwin

Goon Squad, Big Man

Nicole Merat

Tim's Mom

Terry Snead

Kingmaker

Tyson Scott Beckett

Young Tim

Jesse Anthony

Tim Travers Double

Kody Higginbotham

Potato

Alex Wolfe

Homeless man

Kevin Curtis

Tim Travers Double

Brock Otterbacher

Goon Squad, Mutton Chop

J.D. McKee

Goon Squad, Knife Guy