Scottie Thompson

Sara

Jane Seymour

Vivian

Jeff Fahey

Ray

Casper Van Dien

Ash Henson

Scott Wichmann

Larry

Madeline Zima

Lily

Frances Mitchell

Mrs. Tinnell

Sean Patrick Flanery

Mark Futterman

Ben Savage

Carl

Eyal Podell

Tyler

Richard Moll

Old Vic

Ron Canada

Winchester

Mary Elizabeth McDonough

Elizabeth

Richard Riehle

Chairman McCarren

Liberty the Dog

Dobie

Jennifer Massey

Jeanne

Scott Winters

Dave Boyers

Martin Thompson

The Minister

Barry Papick

Tourist

Sara Elizabeth Timmins

Irene

Brian Wimer

Russell

Tamara Johnson

Dottie

Jennifer Hines

Town Clerk (as Jennifer Hines Hall)

Katrina Garibaldi

Ainsley

Charles Hooper

Bob

Steve Mason

Cameraman

Chinah Helmandollar-Jewell

Miss Virginia (as Chinah Helmandollar)

Dee Dee Bondurant

Dee Dee

Gabriel Suttle

Remy

Rachel Rose Lynch

Catherine

Mary Alice Timmins

Grandma

Sarah Vakos

Teen Sara

Madelyn Schloss

Young Lily

Michael McKay

Dispatcher (as Michael J. McKay)

Kay Mancini

Miranda

Susan Timmins

Erica

Elizabeth K. Wilson

Young Sara (as Elizabeth Katherine Wilson)

Tim Ernandes

Tim the DJ

Gigi Raines

Receptionist

Lee Hussey

Helicopter Pilot

Barefoot West

Falcon's Bar Band

Diamondback

Wine Festival Band

Davina

'Smithy'

Steve Cole

Mourner / Bar Patron (uncredited)

Christy Leigh

Bar Patron / Festival Guest (uncredited)

Lauren Paul

Bar Patron (uncredited)

David Witt

Mourner in pink shirt (uncredited)

Derek Young

Bar Patron (uncredited)