Loren Dean

Billy Bathgate

Dustin Hoffman

Dutch Schultz

Nicole Kidman

Drew Preston

Bruce Willis

Bo Weinberg

Steve Buscemi

Irving

Stanley Tucci

Lucky Luciano

Steven Hill

Otto Berman

Billy Jaye

Mickey

John Costelloe

Lulu

Timothy Jerome

Dixie Davis

Mike Starr

Julie Martin

Robert F. Colesberry

Jack Kelly

Stephen Joyce

Mr. Hines

Frances Conroy

Mary Behan

Moira Kelly

Becky

Kevin Corrigan

Arnold

Rob Kramer

Billy's Gang

Xander Berkeley

Harvey Preston

Katharine Houghton

Charlotte

Jack Mulcahy

Fire Inspector

Kenny Vance

Dutch's Thug

Teddy Cleanthes

Supervisor

Barry McGovern

John Moraitis

Lucianno's Bodyguard