Justin McElroy

Self / Chris Evergreen

Travis McElroy

Self

Griffin McElroy

Self

Clint McElroy

Self / Santa Claus

Carol McElroy

Self

Teresa McElroy

Self

Rachel McElroy

Self / Narrator

Sydnee McElroy

Self / Tabatha Bigcity

Sam Reich

Self

John Green

Self

Johnny Stanton

Self

Jasper William Cartwright

Self

Jason Charles Miller

Self

Amy Dallen

Self

Montaigne

Self

Mae-Marie Gilbert

Self

Gary Gilbert

Self

Brittany Ochoa

Self

Jake Pauwels

Self

Charlie McElroy

Holly Bigcity

Cooper McElroy

Susan Evergreen

Tommy Smirl

Mr. Bigcity

Mary Smirl

Queen Evergreen

Leslie McElroy

Self (uncredited) (archive footage)