Amber Tamblyn

Tibby Rollins

Alexis Bledel

Lena Kaligaris

America Ferrera

Carmen Lowell

Blake Lively

Bridget Vreeland

Rachel Nichols

Julia Beckwith

Tom Wisdom

Ian

Rachel Ticotin

Christina Lowell

Leonardo Nam

Brian McBrian

Michael Rady

Kostas Dounas

Shohreh Aghdashloo

Professor Nasrin Mehani

Blythe Danner

Greta

Jesse Williams

Leo

Lucy Hale

Effie Kaligaris

Kyle MacLachlan

Bill Kerr (uncredited)

Maria Konstadarou

Yia Yia

Ernie Lively

Franz Vreeland

Stevie Ray Dallimore

Nigel O'Bannon

Alison Folland

Stage Manager Margaret

Zacharoula Klimatsaki

Melia

Nathaniel Martello-White

Dig Site Student Ray (as Nathaniel Martello)

Emmanuel Leconte

Dig Site Student Miles

Maryann Urbano

Art Teacher Annika (as Maryanne Urbano)

Paul Coughlan

David Breckman

Rebekah Aramini

Ariadne Kaligaris

Cory Nichols

Nicky Rollins

Carly Rose Sonenclar

Katherine Rollins

Erik Jensen

Video Store Manager Phil

Adrienne Bailon-Houghton

Cute Video Couple Girl

Cannon Smith

Cute Video Couple Guy

Dylan Jude Sheridan

Male Video Store Customer (as Dylan Sheridan)

Lindsay Michelle Nader

Female Video Store Customer (as Lindsay Nader)

Crystal McCrary

Mom with Screaming Kids (as Crystal McCrary Anthony)

Nicole Patrick

Apprentice Actor #1

Josh Caras

Apprentice Actor #2

Kiely Williams

Yaffa Waitress

Max Woertendyke

Yale Stagehand

Victor Slezak

Doctor

Marceline Hugot

Nurse

Harry L. Seddon

Tibby's Dad

Kendall Cross

Marlene Vreeland (uncredited)