Madelaine Petsch

Maya

Richard Brake

Sheriff Rotter

Ema Horvath

Shelly / Pinup

Gabriel Basso

Gregory / Scarecrow

Pedro Leandro

Deputy Walters

Rachel Shenton

Debbie

George Young

Howard

Kyle Breitkopf

Teenage Gregory / Scarecrow

Finn Cofell

Teenage Pinup

Stevee Davies

Dougie

Hannah Galway

Claire

Sara Freedland

Annie

Dani Klupsch

Carrie

Ella Bruccoleri

Jasmine

Krystal Ellsworth

Dollface

Pablo Sandstrom

Neil

Janis Ahern

Carol

Stephanie Aubertin

Teenage Dollface

Nicholas Chaif

Sleazy Guy (as Nicolas Chaif)

Jake Cogman

Young Scarecrow

Leo Petrus

Judge

Canaan Davison

Teenage Lumberjack (as Canaan Davidson)

Nola Wallace

Young Pinup

Ben Cartwright

Rudy

Joel Labelle

Man

Eric Hathern

Radio Preacher (voice)

Noah P.

Aiden